Docket Contents

Project Summary: Highway Investigation - 126 Docket Items - HWY18MH009

Description: Other

Mode: Highway

NTSB Number: HWY18MH009

Date of Accident: 03/15/2018

City: Miami

State / Region: FL

Country: United States

Project Type: Investigation


Docket Information

Creation Date: 07/24/18

Last Modified: 04/21/2021 2:14 PM

Public Release Date & Time: 10/08/2019 11:00 AM


Docket Items: 126

#

Title

Pgs

Photo

Type

1 NTSB - ADOPTED BOARD REPORT HAR-19/02 152 0 Text/Image
2 DOCKET ITEM PLACEHOLDER PETITION FOR RECONSIDERATION SUBMITTED THROUGH COUNSEL BY DR. SHAMA 1 0 Text/Image
3 PARTY MEMBERS CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FOR DR. SHAMAA��S SUBMISSION OF PETITION FOR RECONSIDERATION 5 0 Text/Image
4 FIGG BRIDGE ENGINEERS, INC. RESPONSE TO DR. SHAMAA��S SUBMISSION OF PETITION FOR RECONSIDERATION 42 0 Text/Image
5 NTSB BOARD RESPONSE TO DR. SHAMAA��S SUBMISSION OF PETITION FOR RECONSIDERATION 4 0 Text/Image
6 PEDESTRIAN BRIDGE COLLAPSE SUMMARY 1 0 Text/Image
7 PRELIMINARY REPORT 4 0 Text/Image
8 INVESTIGATIVE UPDATE #1 6 0 Text/Image
9 INVESTIGATIVE UPDATE #2 2 0 Text/Image
10 SURVIVAL FACTORS AND VEHICLE GROUP CHAIRMAN'S FACTUAL REPORT 10 0 Text/Image
11 SF AND VEHICLE ATTACHMENT MDPD REPORT 5 0 Text/Image
12 SURVIVAL AND VEHICLE ATTACHMENT MDPD INCIDENT REPORT 45 0 Text/Image
13 SF AND VEHICLE ATTACHMENT FHP INCIDENT REPORT 14 0 Text/Image
14 SF AND VEHICLE ATTACHMENT - FIU COMMUNICATIONS EVENT RECORD 13 0 Text/Image
15 SF AND VEHICLE ATTACHMENT FIU PD REPORT 11 0 Text/Image
16 SF AND VEHICLE ATTACHMENT FIU EOC ACTION PLAN AND STATEMENTS 17 0 Text/Image
17 SF AND VEHICLE ATTACHMENT SWEETWATER INCIDENT RECALL REPORT 12 0 Text/Image
18 SF AND VEHICLE ATTACHMENT DORAL INCIDENT RECALL REPORT 11 0 Text/Image
19 SF AND VEHICLE ATTACHMENT MDFR INFORMATION 5 0 Text/Image
20 SF AND VEHICLE ATTACHMENT NTSB INTERVIEWS 21 0 Text/Image
21 CORRADINO GROUP WITNESS INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT 47 0 Text/Image
22 VSL TRANSCRIPTS 63 0 Text/Image
23 LOUIS BERGER INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT 33 0 Text/Image
24 GEORGE'S CRANE SERVICE INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT 34 0 Text/Image
25 FIGG INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT 295 0 Text/Image
26 FDOT INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT 27 0 Text/Image
27 BPA TRANSCRIPTS 127 0 Text/Image
28 MCM INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPTION 100 0 Text/Image
29 STRUCTURAL GROUP OF SOUTH FLORIDA INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT 40 0 Text/Image
30 BRIDGE FACTORS GROUP CHAIRMAN'S FACTUAL REPORT 206 0 Text/Image
31 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 1 - T.Y. LIN INTERNATIONAL SCOPE OF WORK FOR 2013 GRANT SUBMISSION 14 0 Text/Image
32 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 2 - EMAIL FROM MR. KENNETH JESSELL OF FIU TO MR. DAN WALSH OF NTSB DATED JUNE 8, 2018 2 0 Text/Image
33 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 3 - TIGER ORIGINAL GRANT AGREEMENT DATED JUNE 5, 2014 26 0 Text/Image
34 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 4 - TIGER GRANT ADDENDUM NO. 1 DATED JANUARY 12, 2016 21 0 Text/Image
35 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 5 - TIGER GRANT AMENDMENT NO. 2 DATED DECEMBER 11, 2017 16 0 Text/Image
36 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 6 - FDOT LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM (LAP) MANUAL CHAPTER 3 DATED SEPTEMBER 18, 2013 9 0 Text/Image
37 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 7 - EMAIL FROM MS. XIOMARA NUNEZ OF FDOT TO MR. DAN WALSH OF NTSB DATED AUGUST 17, 2018 3 0 Text/Image
38 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 8 - FDOT LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM (LAP) AGREEMENT DATED JUNE 23, 2014 22 0 Text/Image
39 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 9 - FDOT LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM (LAP) SUPPLEMENTAL AGREEMENT NO. 1 DATED JUNE 2, 2017 7 0 Text/Image
40 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 10 - FDOT LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM (LAP) AMENDMENT EXTENSION REQUEST DATED JANUARY 2, 2018 2 0 Text/Image
41 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 11 - FIU DESIGN BUILD MAXIMUM PRICE REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS 56 0 Text/Image
42 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 12 - FIU PEDESTRIAN BRIDGE DESIGN CRITERIA DATED JUNE 2014 81 0 Text/Image
43 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 13 - LETTER TO MR. JORGE J. RIVERA, DISTRICT VI TRANSPORTATION ENGINEER, FHWA, FROM MR. AIAH YASSIN, DISTRICT LOCAL PROGRAM ADMINISTRATOR, FDOT, DATED NOVEMBER 10, 2015 19 0 Text/Image
44 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 14 - LETTER TO MR. JORGE J. RIVERA, DISTRICT VI TRANSPORTATION ENGINEER, FHWA, FROM MR. AIAH YASSIN, DISTRICT LOCAL PROGRAM ADMINISTRATOR, FDOT, DATED AUGUST 23, 2016 20 0 Text/Image
45 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 15 - FIU DESIGN-BUILD CONTRACT, ENTERED INTO BY THE FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL UNIVERSITY BOARD OF TRUSTEES AND MUNILLA CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT (MCM) DATED JANUARY 14, 2016 15 0 Text/Image
46 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 16 - FIU GENERAL SPECIFICATIONS FOR DESIGN-BUILD CONTRACT BETWEEN FIU AND MCM, REVISED JUNE 9, 2014 177 0 Text/Image
47 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 17 - FIU STANDARD PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT, ENTERED INTO BY THE FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL UNIVERSITY BOARD OF TRUSTEES AND BOLTON PEREZ & ASSOCIATES (BPA) DATED SEPTEMBER 23, 2016 59 0 Text/Image
48 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 18 - STANDARD FORM OF AGREEMENT BETWEEN DESIGN-BUILDER AND DESIGN CONSULTANT, ENTERED INTO BY MCM AND FIGG BRIDGE ENGINEERS, INC. DATED APRIL 28, 2016 35 0 Text/Image
49 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 19 - AGREEMENT ENTERED INTO BY FIGG BRIDGE ENGINEERS, INC. AND LOUIS BERGER DATED SEPTEMBER 16, 2016 44 0 Text/Image
50 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 20 - FDOT AVERAGE ANNUAL DAILY TRAFFIC (AADT) AND LANE WIDTHS ON SW 8TH STREET 7 0 Text/Image
51 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 21 - BPA CRACKS REPORT NO. 1 - EMAIL FROM MR. JOSE MORALES OF BPA TO MR. RODRIGO ISAZA OF MCM DATED FEBRUARY 13, 2018 9 0 Text/Image
52 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 22 - BPA CRACKS REPORT NO. 2 - EMAIL FROM MR. JOSE MORALES OF BPA TO MR. RODRIGO ISAZA OF MCM DATED FEBRUARY 28, 2018 10 0 Text/Image
53 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 23 - TEXTS FROM MR. KEVIN HANSON OF STRUCTURAL TECHNOLOGIES ON HIS MOBILE DEVICE DATED MARCH 10, 2018 8 0 Text/Image
54 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 24 - EMAIL FROM MR. RODRIGO ISAZA OF MCM TO MR. DWIGHT DEMPSEY OF FIGG DATED MARCH 12, 2018 20 0 Text/Image
55 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 25 - EMAIL FROM MR. DWIGHT DEMPSEY OF FIGG TO MR. RODRIGO ISAZA OF MCM DATED MARCH 13, 2018 AT 9 45 A.M. 3 0 Text/Image
56 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 26 - BPA CRACKS REPORT NO. 3 - EMAIL FROM MR. JOSE MORALES OF BPA TO MR. RODRIGO ISAZA OF MCM DATED MARCH 13, 2018 21 0 Text/Image
57 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 27 - EMAIL FROM MR. DWIGHT DEMPSEY OF FIGG TO MR. RODRIGO ISAZA OF MCM DATED MARCH 13, 2018 AT 5 18 22 P.M. 6 0 Text/Image
58 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 28 - EMAIL FROM MR. SAM NUNEZ OF STRUCTURAL TECHNOLOGIES TO MR. RODRIGO ISAZA OF MCM DATED MARCH 14, 2018 9 0 Text/Image
59 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 29 - EMAIL FROM MR. RODRIGO ISAZA OF MCM TO MR. DWIGHT DEMPSEY OF FIGG DATED MARCH 14, 2018 15 0 Text/Image
60 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 30 - BPA 3/15/18 MEETING MINUTES 4 0 Text/Image
61 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 31 - FIGG 3/15/18 MEETING MINUTES 5 0 Text/Image
62 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 32 - FIGG 3/15/18 POWER POINT PRESENTATION 49 0 Text/Image
63 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 33 - EMAIL FROM MR. ALAN PHIPPS OF FIGG TO MR. DAN WALSH OF NTSB DATED JULY 12, 2018 2 0 Text/Image
64 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 34 - EMAIL FROM MR. ALFREDO REYNA OF FDOT TO MR. ALBERTO DELGADO OF FIU DATED OCTOBER 12, 2016 2 0 Text/Image
65 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 35 - MINUTES OF MEETING PREPARED BY BOLTON PEREZ & ASSOCIATES (BPA) WITH SIGN-IN SHEET ATTACHED DATED OCTOBER 31, 2016 3 0 Text/Image
66 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 36 - EMAIL FROM MR. JOAQUIN (JAKE) PEREZ OF BPA TO MR. DAN WALSH OF NTSB DATED AUGUST 7, 2018 3 0 Text/Image
67 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 37 - EMAIL FROM MR. ALAN PHIPPS OF FIGG TO MR. DAN WALSH OF NTSB DATED AUGUST 27, 2018 2 0 Text/Image
68 FACTORS ATTACHMENT 38 - FIU PEDESTRIAN BRIDGE SUPERSTRUCTURE PLANS INCLUDING CONSTRUCTION SEQUENCE PLANS 55 0 Text/Image
69 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 39 - FIU PEDESTRIAN BRIDGE GENERAL PLAN AND ELEVATION AND FOUNDATION LAYOUT 5 0 Text/Image
70 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 40 - PERCENT FIU BRIDGE COMPLETION AT THE TIME OF THE COLLAPSE 2 0 Text/Image
71 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 41 - EMAIL FROM MR. JOHN ENGBERG OF BARNHART CRANE AND RIGGING TO MR. DAN WALSH OF NTSB DATED AUGUST 20, 2018 3 0 Text/Image
72 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 42 - COMPARISON OF FDOT PROJECTS VERSUS LAP PROJECTS FOR THE LAST 5 YEARS 5 0 Text/Image
73 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 43 - FDOT LOCAL AGENCY PROGRAM (LAP) MANUAL, CHAPTERS 19 AND 20, DATED MARCH 28, 2008 11 0 Text/Image
74 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 44 - FDOT PLANS PREPARATION MANUAL (PPM), VOLUME 1, CHAPTER 26 - BRIDGE PROJECT DEVELOPMENT, JANUARY 1, 2014 67 0 Text/Image
75 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 45 - FDOT STRUCTURES DESIGN OFFICE (SDO) ELECTRONIC REVIEW AND EMAIL COMMENTS ON SUBMITTAL PHASES FOR THE SIGNATURE PEDESTRIAN BRIDGE 141 0 Text/Image
76 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 46 - EMAIL FROM MR. TOM ANDRES OF FDOT TO MR. DAN WALSH OF NTSB DATED MAY 3, 2018 9 0 Text/Image
77 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 47 - EMAIL FROM MR. TOM ANDRES OF FDOT TO MR. DAN WALSH OF NTSB DATED APRIL 26, 2018 2 0 Text/Image
78 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 48 - 100% CERTIFICATION LETTERS SIGNED AND SEALED BY LOUIS BERGER 4 0 Text/Image
79 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 49 - FDOT STANDARD SPECIFICATIONS FOR ROAD AND BRIDGE CONSTRUCTION, DIVISION II - CONSTRUCTION DETAILS, STRUCTURES, DATED JANUARY 2015 4 0 Text/Image
80 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 50 - EXCERPTS FROM RULE 14-75 OF THE FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE 5 0 Text/Image
81 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 51 - EMAILS FROM MR. TOM ANDRES OF FDOT TO MR. DAN WALSH OF NTSB DATED APRIL 20, 2018 AND MAY 22, 2018 2 0 Text/Image
82 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 52 - EMAIL FROM MS. ROBIN MALACREA OF LOUIS BERGER TO MS. CARLIAYN KELL OF FDOT DATED DECEMBER 28, 2016 2 0 Text/Image
83 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 53 - LETTER FROM MS. CARLIAYN KELL OF FDOT TO MR. ERNESTO POLO OF LOUIS BERGER DATED JANUARY 17, 2017 13 0 Text/Image
84 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 54 - AASHTO LOAD AND RESISTANCE FACTOR DESIGN (LRFD) BRIDGE DESIGN SPECIFICATIONS, 7TH EDITION, 2014, WITH 2015 INTERIMS, GUIDANCE ON REDUNDANCY 7 0 Text/Image
85 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 55 - FDOT STRUCTURES DESIGN GUIDELINES (SDG), STRUCTURES MANUAL VOLUME 1, DATED JANUARY 2015 5 0 Text/Image
86 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 56 - FDOT STANDARD SPECIFICATIONS FOR ROAD AND BRIDGE CONSTRUCTION, DIVISION II - CONSTRUCTION DETAILS, SECTION 102 MAINTENANCE OF TRAFFIC, DATED JANUARY 2015 3 0 Text/Image
87 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 57 - FDOT CONSTRUCTION PROJECT ADMINISTRATION MANUAL, SECTION 9.1 MAINTENANCE OF TRAFFIC, 9.1.8 RECOMMENDED ACTION TO SHUT DOWN A PROJECT DUE TO MOT DEFICIENCIES, DATED APRIL 11, 2014 6 0 Text/Image
88 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 58 - FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE 61G15-18.011 3 0 Text/Image
89 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 59 - FDOT TWO-LANE BLANKET ROAD CLOSURE 4 0 Text/Image
90 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 60 - FDOT GENERAL USE PERMIT 97 0 Text/Image
91 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 61 - MCM AND FIGG BRIDGE ENGINEERS, INC. AGREEMENT, CHANGE ORDER REQUEST NO. 1, DATED FEBRUARY 6, 2017 5 0 Text/Image
92 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 62 - MCM AND FIGG BRIDGE ENGINEERS, INC. AGREEMENT, CHANGE ORDER REQUEST NO. 8, DATED OCTOBER 18, 2017 14 0 Text/Image
93 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 63 - FIGG BRIDGE ENGINEERS, INC. ATTACHMENT DATA AND TIMELINE 656 0 Text/Image
94 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 64 - BOLTON PEREZ & ASSOCIATES (BPA) ATTACHMENT COLD JOINT DATA 18 0 Text/Image
95 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 65 - FDOT'S FOLLOW-UP TO NTSB QUESTIONS 13 0 Text/Image
96 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 66 - MCMA��S ATTACHMENT SUBCONTRACT AGREEMENT DATA 23 0 Text/Image
97 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 67 - FDOT CONSTRUCTION PROJECT ADMINISTRATION MANUAL, SECTION 4.1 ADMINISTRATION OF CONSULTANT CEI CONTRACTS, DATED NOVEMBER 2, 2012 8 0 Text/Image
98 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 68 - FIU PEDESTRIAN BRIDGE PYLON DIAPHRAGM DIMENSIONS AND REINFORCEMENT PLANS 37 0 Text/Image
99 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 69 - AASHTO LOAD AND RESISTANCE FACTOR DESIGN (LRFD) BRIDGE DESIGN SPECIFICATIONS, 7TH EDITION, 2014, WITH 2015 INTERIMS, GUIDANCE ON INTENTIONALLY ROUGHENED SURFACE 3 0 Text/Image
100 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 70 - FIU SUPERSTRUCTURE - LONGITUDINAL & TRANSVERSE RFC DESIGN CALCULATIONS 1457 0 Text/Image
101 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 71 - FIU SUPERSTRUCTURE - MISCELLANEOUS DETAILS RFC DESIGN CALCULATIONS 399 0 Text/Image
102 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 72 - FDOT LETTER TO LOUIS BERGER DATED MARCH 18, 2013 INDICATING STATUS IS INSUFFICIENT FOR 4.3.1 COMPLEX BRIDGE DESIGN - CONCRETE 17 0 Text/Image
103 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 73 - FHWA ASSESSMENT OF BRIDGE DESIGN AND PERFORMANCE 91 0 Text/Image
104 BRIDGE FACTORS ATTACHMENT 74 - FHWA TURNER-FAIRBANK HIGHWAY RESEARCH CENTER FACTUAL REPORT FOR CONCRETE INTERFACE UNDER MEMBERS 11 AND 12 16 0 Text/Image
105 BRIDGE FACTORS PHOTOGRAPHS 1 THROUGH 111 84 111 Text/Image
106 BRIDGE FACTORS PHOTOGRAPHS - FIGG BRIDGE ENGINEERS, INC. SUBMITTAL OF PHOTOGRAPHIC EVIDENCE 133 0 Text/Image
107 BRIDGE FACTORS PHOTOGRAPHS - MCMA��S SUBMITTAL OF PHOTOGRAPHIC EVIDENCE 9 4 Text/Image
108 FIGG FACTOR OF SAFETY PRESENTATION AND CALCULATIONS 403 0 Text/Image
109 FHWA ASSESSMENT OF FIGG FACTOR OF SAFETY PRESENTATION AND CALCULATION 3 0 Text/Image
110 PERSONAL ELECTRONIC DEVICE - SPECIALIST'S FACTUAL REPORT 2 0 Text/Image
111 SECURITY VIDEO FACTUAL REPORT 19 0 Text/Image
112 ERRATA - SECURITY VIDEO FACTUAL REPORT 2 0 Text/Image
113 MATERIALS LABORATORY STUDY REPORT - TIO2 NANOPARTICLES IN CONCRETE 4 0 Text/Image
114 MATERIALS LABORATORY FACTUAL REPORT - FHWA TFHRC POST-TENSIONING SYSTEM PERFORMANCE TESTING 28 0 Text/Image
115 MATERIALS LABORATORY STUDY REPORT - MEMBER 11-12 SURFACE ROUGHNESS 16 0 Text/Image
116 MATERIALS LABORATORY FACTUAL REPORT - FHWA TFHRC STEEL AND CONCRETE MATERIALS TESTING 67 0 Text/Image
117 COMBINED SIGNED PARTY FORMS 7 0 Text/Image
118 NTSB REVOCATION OF OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH ADMINISTRATION (OSHA) PARTY MEMBER STATUS 2 0 Text/Image
119 MIAMI FL TECHNICAL REVIEW COVER LETTER AND EMAIL CORRESPONDENCE 9 0 Text/Image
120 FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION PARTY SUBMISSION; FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS 4 0 Text/Image
121 MCM PARTY SUBMISSION; FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS, RECOMMENDATIONS, AND ATTACHMENTS 125 0 Text/Image
122 FIGG BRIDGE ENGINEERS, INC. PARTY SUBMISSION; FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS, RECOMMENDATIONS, AND ATTACHMENTS 344 0 Text/Image
123 PARTY LETTER DATED 10-05-19 REQUESTING DELAY IN OPENING PUBLIC DOCKET AND CHAIRMAN SUMWALT'S RESPONSE LETTER DATED 10-07-19 3 0 Text/Image
124 FIGG'S PRESENTATION OF PARTY SUBMISSION TO THE NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SAFETY BOARD 107 0 Text/Image
125 MODJESKI AND MASTERS EVALUATION OF DOCKET ITEMS FROM LOUIS BERGER 13 0 Text/Image
126 LETTER TO CHAIRMAN SUMWALT FROM MR. LEE MOAK REGARDING FHWA ASSESSMENT 3 0 Text/Image